Abstract
Collaborative online learning offers opportunities for knowledge sharing, peer support and participation in open, distance and e-learning (ODeL) environments. However, digital inequality often limits students’ access to technologies, connectivity and institutional support, requiring them to draw on both formal and informal learning networks. This article explores how collaborative learning contributes to the development of social capital among students studying at a South African ODeL institution. The study draws on a qualitative case study involving 22 students in an online module, using four focus groups and 12 individual interviews. An integrated conceptual framework comprising social capital theory, connectivism and heutagogy was used to examine how students navigate collaborative learning in contexts of digital inequality. The findings indicate that students developed both bonding and bridging social capital through participation in formal and informal learning networks. Bonding social capital emerged through trusted peer relationships that provided emotional and academic support, while bridging social capital expanded access to diverse perspectives and learning opportunities. Students synchronised institutional learning management systems with informal learning spaces and networks, including WhatsApp and face-to-face study groups, to overcome digital inequality and sustain collaborative learning. Collaborative networks also presented challenges, including unequal participation and exclusion.
Contribution: By integrating social capital theory, connectivism and heutagogy, the study provides a richer explanation of how relationships, distributed learning networks, and learner autonomy support participation and inclusion. The findings highlight the value of recognising formal and informal learning networks as complementary learning spaces when designing more inclusive and contextually responsive ODeL environments.
Keywords: collaborative learning; digital inequality; social capital; connectivism; heutagogy; open, distance and e-learning.
Introduction
This article builds on data previously reported in Venter (2018, 2019), which explored how student collaborations contributed to bonding and bridging social capital development in an open, distance and e-learning (ODeL) context. While the original study focused primarily on collaborative learning and the development of bonding and bridging social capital, the findings also revealed evidence of student initiative, self-directed participation, and the strategic use of formal and informal learning networks. These practices suggest that students exercised varying degrees of autonomy in navigating collaborative learning opportunities within a digitally mediated environment. Building on these insights, the current article extends the original analysis through a conceptual integration of social capital theory, connectivism and heutagogy to provide a richer understanding of collaborative learning in contexts of digital inequality. It also extends the earlier work on the synchronisation of formal and informal learning spaces (Venter 2020), with particular attention to mobile-enabled learning networks and their implications for more inclusive ODeL design. Although the empirical base remains the same, the insights and conclusions presented here are distinct from those reported in the earlier publications.
As online learning becomes more central to open and distance education, concerns emerge about how equitably opportunities are provided (Zawacki-Richter & Jung 2022), particularly at a large ODeL institution with a student body drawn from a wide range of social and educational backgrounds (Lephalala & Makoe 2012; Ngubane-Mokiwa 2017). This global expansion of open and distributed learning has prompted renewed calls to frame ODeL not merely as a mode of delivery, but as an evolving ecosystem grounded in openness, equity and learner autonomy, shaped by interconnected systemic conditions (Bozkurt & Stracke 2023; Czerniewicz & Carvalho 2023; Zawacki-Richter 2026; eds. Zawacki-Richter & Jung 2022).
Although collaborative learning is widely promoted in online education, much of the literature assumes stable digital access and focuses primarily on institutionally designed learning environments. Carr (2023) observes that networked learning in African higher education contexts often reveals how structural inequalities, such as uneven digital access and institutional power dynamics, shape who can participate and how. Students often move between formal and informal learning spaces to support their learning (Mpungose 2025). Building on this perspective, the present article examines how collaborative learning contributes to the development of bonding and bridging social capital within formal and informal learning networks and how students mobilise these networks in contexts of digital inequality.
In digitally unequal contexts, the Learning Management System (LMS) often functions as a high-barrier entry point, while informal platforms provide low-cost, mobile-first solutions. The act of synchronising these spaces is not merely pragmatic; it is a critical pedagogical strategy that enables students to mobilise both bonding and bridging social capital. Viewed through a social capital lens, these collaborative practices highlight the importance of relationships and networks as resources for learning in digitally unequal ODeL environments.
The study was guided by the following research questions:
- How does collaborative learning contribute to the development of bonding and bridging social capital among students in a South African ODeL context?
- How do students utilise formal and informal digital learning spaces to support collaborative learning in contexts of digital inequality?
- What implications do these collaborative learning practices hold for the design of more inclusive ODeL environments?
This article draws on an integrated conceptual framework comprising social capital theory, connectivism and heutagogy. Social capital theory provides a lens for understanding how collaborative relationships function as learning resources, connectivism explains how learning occurs through networks of people and technologies, and heutagogy highlights students’ capacity to shape their own learning pathways. Together, these perspectives provide an integrated framework for understanding how collaborative learning, social capital formation and student participation interact within digitally unequal ODeL environments.
Theoretical framework
Collaborative learning is widely recognised as an important pedagogical approach in ODeL environments because it enables students to construct knowledge through interaction, dialogue and shared problem-solving (Zawacki-Richter & Jung 2022). Through collaborative engagement, students can access diverse perspectives, receive academic and emotional support, and participate more actively in the learning process (Lu, Yang & Yu 2013). However, opportunities for collaboration are not experienced equally by all students. In many ODeL contexts, participation in collaborative learning is shaped by persistent forms of digital inequality, including uneven access to devices, connectivity, digital skills and supportive learning environments (Mpungose 2025).
Collaborative learning in contexts of digital inequality
Digital inequality remains a significant challenge within South African higher education and is particularly evident in ODeL contexts, where learning is mediated primarily through digital technologies (Czerniewicz & Brown 2013). While ODeL has expanded access to higher education for geographically dispersed and historically underrepresented student populations, many students continue to navigate substantial socio-economic and technological constraints (eds. Zawacki-Richter & Jung 2022). These constraints influence not only students’ access to learning resources but also their ability to participate meaningfully in collaborative learning activities and online communities (Mpungose 2025).
The growth of digital technologies has further blurred the boundaries between formal and informal learning spaces. Formal learning typically occurs through institutionally sanctioned platforms such as LMSs, where course content, assessment activities and official communication are managed. Informal learning, by contrast, often occurs through student-initiated networks and social media platforms that facilitate peer interaction, resource sharing and collaborative problem-solving beyond institutional structures (Makoe 2012; Oddone 2023). Rather than operating as separate domains, students frequently move between formal and informal learning spaces in ways that support their learning needs and respond to contextual constraints (Mpungose 2025; Venter 2020).
Recent research suggests that this interaction between formal and informal learning spaces may be particularly important in contexts of digital inequality (Mpungose 2025; Venter 2020). Mpungose (2025) argues that students at South African ODeL institutions often experience challenges when engaging with formal institutional platforms owing to limited digital access and resource constraints, while simultaneously demonstrating high levels of participation through informal platforms such as WhatsApp and other social networking applications. He proposes a more integrated approach that recognises the complementary roles of formal and informal e-learning platforms in supporting meaningful learning and participation.
These observations suggest that collaborative learning in ODeL is shaped by students’ ability to navigate multiple learning spaces, establish relationships and access resources across diverse networks (Mpungose 2025; Oddone 2023). Understanding how students mobilise these networks is therefore essential to understanding collaborative learning in contexts of digital inequality (Lu et al. 2013). Social capital theory provides a useful lens for examining these processes by focusing on how relationships, trust, reciprocity and network connections function as valuable resources for learning (Feng & Tan 2024; Kehrwald & Oztok 2016).
Social capital and collaborative learning networks
Collaborative learning is fundamentally relational and therefore closely aligned with social capital theory. Social capital refers to the resources that individuals can access through relationships, networks and social connections (Bourdieu 1986:249). Within educational contexts, these resources may include information, emotional support, academic guidance, feedback and opportunities for participation. Social capital theory therefore provides a useful lens for understanding how collaborative learning networks create value for students, particularly in contexts where access to formal resources may be constrained (Coleman 1988; Lu et al. 2013; Putnam 2001).
In digitally unequal ODeL environments, social capital may function as a compensatory resource. Students who experience barriers to formal institutional support often rely on peer networks to access information, clarify course requirements, share learning resources and maintain motivation. Collaborative learning networks therefore become important mechanisms through which students navigate structural constraints and sustain participation in their studies (Feng & Tan 2024; Oztok et al. 2015).
Bonding social capital develops through strong, trusting relationships among students who share similar experiences and challenges. These relationships often provide emotional support, encouragement and a sense of belonging (Oztok et al. 2015; Putnam 2001). Bridging social capital, by contrast, emerges through connections that extend beyond immediate peer groups and provide access to new information, diverse perspectives and broader learning opportunities (Oztok et al. 2015; Putnam 2001). Effective collaborative learning environments often facilitate both forms of social capital, enabling students to balance support, a sense of belonging and access to new knowledge (Daniel, Schwier & McCalla 2003; Oztok et al. 2015).
The development of social capital increasingly occurs across both formal and informal learning spaces. While institutional platforms provide structured opportunities for interaction, informal networks often support more immediate, flexible and student-driven forms of engagement. The movement between these spaces enables students to activate different forms of social capital according to their learning needs, technological circumstances and social connections (Mpungose 2025; Venter 2019).
While social capital theory explains the value of relationships and network connections, connectivism focuses on how learning occurs through those connections. Connectivist perspectives suggest that learning occurs through participation in distributed networks of people, resources and technologies (Downes 2007; Siemens 2005). In ODeL contexts characterised by uneven access to formal support and persistent forms of digital inequality, students frequently exercise agency by creating and maintaining informal learning networks that complement institutional learning environments (Mpungose 2025). These networked practices mirror the personal learning networks described by Oddone (2023) and resonate with the ways participants in this study leveraged peer relationships, social media platforms and digital communication tools to access academic, technical and emotional support. Such practices illustrate how learning extends beyond formal course structures into self-organised spaces where students actively negotiate challenges, share resources and co-construct knowledge.
Viewed through a social capital lens, these informal networks provide access not only to information and learning resources but also to relationships that foster belonging and trust, and create opportunities for academic advancement (Mpungose 2025; Oztok et al. 2015).
Research methods and design
A qualitative case study design was employed to explore students’ experiences of collaborative online learning within a single fully online module at a South African ODeL institution. The design was selected to enable in-depth exploration of interactional practices, peer relationships and meaning-making processes within a bounded educational context.
This article draws on data generated through a qualitative study conducted as part of a completed doctoral investigation into student collaboration in a South African ODeL context (Venter 2018). The study was informed by an interpretivist paradigm and explored students’ experiences of collaborative learning and participation in learning networks. The present article builds on the original study through a conceptual integration of social capital theory, connectivism and heutagogy to explore collaborative learning in contexts of digital inequality.
The study involved 22 participants drawn from a cohort of 369 students in one online module. Data were generated through four focus group interviews and 12 individual online interviews. The focus groups identified shared experiences and emerging themes related to collaborative learning, while the individual interviews explored these themes in greater depth and continued until data saturation was achieved. The focus group and interview questions explored students’ experiences of collaborative learning, participation in formal and informal learning networks, peer interaction, sources of academic and social support, and the perceived value and challenges of these collaborative relationships.
The four focus group interviews were held at two regional campuses, whereas the 12 individual interviews were conducted online. Participants were purposively selected to ensure variation in academic performance and in participation in collaborative learning activities. This enabled the study to capture diverse experiences of online collaboration and social capital development. To protect participants’ identities, pseudonyms were assigned to all participants and are used throughout the findings when presenting quotations.
Interview and focus group data were transcribed verbatim and analysed using an iterative thematic analysis approach. Analysis followed a series of structured steps. Firstly, transcripts were read repeatedly to achieve familiarisation with the data. Secondly, initial codes were generated inductively to capture patterns in student interactions, collaboration practices, peer support and participants’ descriptions of how they managed their own learning. Related codes were then grouped into broader themes that reflect the key patterns across the datasets.
Trustworthiness was enhanced through prolonged engagement with the dataset, iterative coding, comparison across multiple data sources, and ongoing reflection during the analysis process. The use of both focus group and individual interview data enabled triangulation and contributed to the credibility of the findings.
The inductive thematic analysis resulted in four interrelated themes that describe how students navigated collaborative learning in contexts of digital inequality. Collectively, the themes illustrate how students navigated formal and informal learning spaces, developed bonding and bridging social capital through collaborative relationships, and demonstrated self-directed learning in contexts of digital inequality.
The themes were subsequently interpreted through the complementary lenses of social capital theory, connectivism and heutagogy. Social capital theory informed the interpretation of collaborative relationships and networks, connectivism provided a lens for understanding learning across distributed formal and informal learning spaces, and heutagogy informed the interpretation of students’ increasing self-directed participation in response to contexts of digital inequality.
Ethical considerations
Ethical clearance to conduct this study was obtained from the University of South Africa PRC Ethics Review Committee (No. 2016_PRC_ERC_005). Institutional permission was granted by the host university, and all participants provided informed consent. Participation was voluntary; informed consent was obtained; confidentiality and anonymity were maintained; and no new data were collected for this secondary analysis.
Results
The thematic analysis identified four interrelated themes that illuminate students’ collaborative learning experiences in contexts of digital inequality. Together, the themes demonstrate how students navigated unequal access to learning resources through social capital, formal and informal learning spaces, and collaborative learning.
Bonding social capital in collaborative learning networks
The first theme concerns the development of bonding social capital through collaborative learning networks. Bonding social capital emerged within emotionally supportive peer groups, often grounded in shared backgrounds, languages or life experiences. Several participants shared that they were members of long-standing study groups who interacted regularly on a variety of platforms. They revealed that their groups provided a safe place for them, and they helped each other prepare for assessment and final examinations. Petra, female student, called the close group her ‘family’. Omi, female student, explained that she was a member of an online group that supported her learning, noting that:
‘… you are not isolated with your own books, but there is interaction. It can make you a better learner, more confident, and get other ideas and prepare you.’ (Omi, female student)
The close-knit ties in the different types of groups provided familiarity, trust and mutual encouragement, and became safe spaces for resource sharing and academic motivation.
However, the strength of these networks also introduced certain limitations. While they fostered solidarity, they could become insular, excluding students perceived as different or disengaged and potentially reinforcing homogeneity in thought. For instance, there were reports that certain groups started to exclude other students from their conversations if they did not think those students made meaningful contributions. Omi, female student, explained that peers were ignored ‘if they couldn’t respond properly’.
Bridging social capital and access to diverse perspectives
The second theme relates to bridging social capital and access to diverse perspectives. Participants described extending their learning beyond close peer networks by engaging with a wider range of people, ideas and resources.
Bridging social capital developed through weaker, more diffuse ties. In this case, connections between previously unacquainted peers were formed through course-based interactions or informal digital platforms such as WhatsApp. These ties, while less emotionally intimate, played a vital role in exposing students to diverse viewpoints and promoting cognitive expansion. Students accessed non-redundant information, learned from peers outside their immediate circles, and acted as brokers of knowledge between groups. For instance, Nelson, male student, commented as follows on the benefits of working with peers that she had never met before:
‘It helps a lot, it brings attention to certain things which you might not be aware of and in your interaction with other students, you are able to learn. It did help. … And you are able to gauge yourself, to see how much you know of the work … it gives you a sort of feel of how far you are with your study materials.’ (Nelson, male student)
Another participant commented that the feedback from peers enabled him ‘to look at something in a different way’.
The collaboration with peers further prompted Moipone, female student, to:
‘[S]tart learning [thinking about], your way of grasping knowledge. I mean, you start learning how your brain works, how you grasp different ways you can learn.’ (Moipone, female student)
Navigating formal and informal learning spaces
The third theme concerns students’ navigation of formal and informal learning spaces. The findings indicate that while mandatory interaction on the LMS did occur, it was limited, as shown by low participation levels and minimal engagement in online discussion forums. Students also expressed frustration, noting that the LMS was difficult to navigate and frequently experienced downtime.
Despite limited engagement on the formal LMS, student feedback indicates that self-initiated collaboration through informal learning networks is extensive and spans multiple platforms. When formal learning environments fail to meet their needs, students actively seek practical alternatives, opting for accessible and relevant digital tools and social media platforms at all hours of the day. These include small face-to-face study groups, WhatsApp groups and other student-driven online spaces.
Jasmin, female student, pointed out:
‘I couldn’t find it on myUnisa [the LMS], and then they [on her WhatsApp group] would say, no, go there and then go there …’ (Jasmine, female student)
Similarly, Zanele, female student, highlighted the benefits of WhatsApp collaboration, explaining that:
‘[B]ecause sometimes you’re in doubt and you doubt if you have the right answer or if you are at the right place and then the other people [on the WhatsApp group] will like go no, this is how we did it and then you’ll know, ok, I am in the right track.’ (Zanele, female student)
Benita, female student, also expressed a preference for WhatsApp, observing that:
‘It is just easier to use than myUnisa [the LMS].’ (Benita, female student)
Furthermore, Vuyo, male student, shared that WhatsApp is more readily accessible to students compared to the formal platform, emphasising its immediacy by saying that:
‘… the better thing of WhatsApp is that everybody is phoning at the same time.’ (Vuyo, male student)
Jasmine, female student, supported this observation, noting that, on WhatsApp:
‘… … the messages would fly around all day.’ (Jasmin, female student)
One participant explained that they turned to WhatsApp to enjoy social interaction, reduce feelings of isolation and seek support. Poppy, female student described the value of this interaction enthusiastically:
‘I do have fun because … it is always good to interact as students. I feel it helps sometimes [more] than being on your own and believing that you understand when you don’t understand, so we get to share ideas.’ (Poppy, female student)
The findings further revealed that students frequently supplemented online interaction with face-to-face engagement, often through established study groups that had developed over time. These groups appeared to play a significant role in students’ learning experiences, providing both academic and social support. Other participants reported meeting regularly with peers at the premises of a third-party service provider, creating opportunities for interaction beyond the formal institutional environment. As a result, students combined online and offline collaborations, moving flexibly between physical and digital spaces according to their learning needs and circumstances. This reflects the distributed and networked nature of learning described in connectivist theory (Downes 2007; Siemens 2005) and supports recent research showing that ODeL students increasingly synchronise formal and informal learning spaces to navigate digital inequality (Feng & Tan 2024; Mpungose 2025; Venter 2020).
The process of synchronising formal and informal spaces underpins the development of both bonding (strong ties) and bridging capital (weak ties) (Venter 2020). The informal interactions fostered a strong sense of belonging, a feature largely absent from exchanges on the LMS. Benita, female student, called it ‘the community that I belong to’. She explained that it enabled students to ‘build confidantes and friendships’. Mattheu, male student, mentioned that his informal group had a ‘groupie feeling’.
There is clear evidence that students meet regularly outside the LMS and cultivate strong social connections. These close ties foster a sense of belonging, offer social support, and enable rich knowledge exchange and deeper discussions across both formal and informal learning spaces. When these spaces are synchronised, students can extend and reinforce their learning experiences by drawing on the strengths of each environment.
At the same time, weaker and more distant ties, formed through occasional or ad hoc interactions, play an important role in bridging gaps between otherwise disconnected students. Through the alignment of formal and informal learning contexts, these connections help expand networks, create new relationships, and provide access to diverse perspectives and novel information, thereby enhancing inclusivity within the broader learning community.
These findings demonstrate that formal and informal learning spaces functioned as complementary rather than separate environments. Students strategically moved between these spaces to sustain collaboration, access support and overcome barriers associated with digital inequality.
Collaborative learning in contexts of digital inequality
The fourth theme explores collaborative learning in contexts of digital inequality. The findings indicate that students’ collaborative learning practices were shaped by a range of contextual constraints associated with studying in a digitally unequal ODeL environment, including limited internet connectivity, high data costs, geographical isolation, delayed access to information, and the absence of immediate face-to-face support. Several participants indicated that they depended on workplace facilities and internet connectivity because they lacked reliable internet access and adequate laptops at home.
Participants also expressed frustration with delayed or limited lecturer feedback. Leana, female student complained that online lecturers ‘… didn’t come to us saying this is where you are wrong or right’, while Omi, female student, explained that ‘… people were waiting for replies from the lecturer, but nothing [came forth]’.
Furthermore, some participants expressed feelings of being lost and isolated in the online environment. A participant recounted:
‘… it was a shock [I] don’t know what to do, sitting in front of my computer.’ (Petra, female student)
These constraints often affected students’ ability to engage consistently with institutional learning platforms and formal channels of communication.
The findings further revealed that many students maintained regular face-to-face interactions through long-standing study groups as a practical strategy to overcome some of the challenges associated with online learning and digital inequality. These groups enabled students to reduce internet costs, obtain immediate academic assistance, share resources and strengthen collaborative relationships established through digital communication channels. For some participants, these offline study groups provided a reliable and accessible source of both academic and social support. Petra, female student, indicated that the study group provided everything she needed to support her learning. The high levels of interaction, trust and reciprocity within these groups also served as a source of motivation. Bina, female student, explained, ‘You feel that if you were not to cooperate, you will be letting them down’.
In response to these challenges, students developed a range of adaptive strategies to support their learning. One of the most common strategies was the creation and use of informal peer networks, particularly through mobile messaging platforms such as WhatsApp. These networks enabled students to exchange information rapidly, clarify academic requirements, share learning resources and foster a sense of belonging during periods of uncertainty and stress. Informal communication channels were often perceived as more accessible, immediate and responsive than formal institutional systems. Vuyo, male student, noted that a greater number of students have access to WhatsApp compared to those who own personal computers or laptops.
Students also demonstrated considerable flexibility in moving between formal and informal learning spaces. While the LMS served as the primary repository for official course information and learning materials, participants frequently relied on peer-generated networks to interpret content, discuss assessments and solve problems collaboratively. Zanele, female student, explained it as follows:
‘Yes, because sometimes you’re in doubt and you doubt if you have the right answer or if you are at the right place and then the other people will like go no, this is how we did it and then you’ll know, ok, I am on the right track.’ (Zanele, female student)
Furthermore, participation across formal and informal platforms created opportunities for students to interact with peers from diverse social, linguistic and geographical contexts. These interactions suggest the potential of collaborative learning to facilitate engagement across different backgrounds and experiences. Rather than functioning as separate environments, formal and informal spaces operated in a complementary manner, allowing students to access relevant resources, advice and guidance through multiple channels.
The findings further suggest that collaborative learning served as an important mechanism through which students navigated the challenges of digital inequality. Through participation in peer networks, students gained access to resources, assistance and collaborative opportunities that might otherwise have remained unavailable. Collaborative relationships helped to reduce feelings of isolation, compensate for limitations in connectivity and institutional responsiveness, and support continued participation in learning despite contextual constraints. These findings highlight the important role that informal peer networks can play in mitigating some of the effects of digital inequality within ODeL environments.
Discussion
The discussion interprets the four themes presented in the Findings section in relation to the three research questions. Rather than discussing each theme separately, the findings are synthesised to explain: (1) how collaborative learning contributes to the development of bonding and bridging social capital, (2) how students navigate formal and informal learning spaces in contexts of digital inequality and (3) what these findings imply for the design of more inclusive ODeL environments. Social capital theory, connectivism and heutagogy provide complementary theoretical lenses through which these findings are interpreted. Although these perspectives originate from different theoretical traditions, they are complementary in explaining how relationships, networks and learner agency interact to support collaborative learning in digitally unequal ODeL environments.
Collaborative learning as a source of bonding and bridging social capital
The first research question explored how collaborative learning contributes to the development of bonding and bridging social capital among students in a South African ODeL context. The findings demonstrate that collaborative learning functions as considerably more than a pedagogical strategy; it enables students to access valuable social resources that support participation, persistence and academic success. Bonding social capital developed through trusted peer relationships characterised by mutual support, belonging and emotional encouragement, while bridging social capital enabled students to access diverse perspectives, information and learning opportunities beyond their immediate social circles.
These findings support social capital theory, which argues that relationships constitute valuable educational resources rather than merely social connections (Coleman 1988; Oztok et al. 2015; Putnam 2001). Consistent with Lu et al. (2013), both bonding and bridging ties contributed to collaborative knowledge construction, although they served different purposes. Strong ties promoted trust and reciprocal support, whereas weaker ties broadened students’ access to new knowledge and alternative viewpoints. Together, these complementary forms of social capital strengthened students’ capacity to participate meaningfully despite the challenges associated with digitally unequal learning environments (Lu et al. 2013; Oztok et al. 2015).
The findings also indicate that social capital is not generated automatically through participation in online learning environments. Rather, it develops through sustained interaction, reciprocity and collaborative engagement across multiple learning contexts (Mpungose 2025; Oztok et al. 2015). This suggests that effective collaborative learning design should intentionally create opportunities for students to develop both bonding and bridging relationships (Lu et al. 2013; Oztok et al. 2015).
Navigating formal and informal learning spaces in contexts of digital inequality
The second research question examined how students utilised formal and informal learning spaces to support collaborative learning in contexts of digital inequality. The findings demonstrate that students actively moved between institutional and student-created learning environments, including the LMS, WhatsApp groups, face-to-face study groups and support centres operated by third-party providers. Rather than functioning as separate environments, these spaces formed interconnected learning networks through which students accessed academic support, exchanged information, solved problems collaboratively and reduced feelings of isolation (Makoe 2012; Oddone 2023).
These findings align strongly with connectivist perspectives, which conceptualise learning as occurring across distributed networks of people, technologies and information sources (Downes 2007; Siemens 2005). Knowledge was not confined to institutional LMSs but emerged through students’ participation in multiple interconnected networks. Particularly within contexts of digital inequality, students compensated for technological and institutional constraints by strategically synchronising formal and informal learning spaces, echoing findings reported by Mpungose (2025), Oddone (2023) and Venter (2020).
Importantly, the findings suggest that students were not passive recipients of institutional provision. Instead, they exercised considerable initiative by identifying learning needs, selecting communication platforms, mobilising peer support and creating alternative pathways for participation when formal systems proved insufficient. These adaptive practices suggest that collaborative learning helped students navigate the effects of digital inequality through networked participation and collective problem-solving (Carr 2023; Doo & Zhu 2025; Mpungose 2025).
Implications for more inclusive open, distance and e-learning environments
The third research question explored the implications of these collaborative learning practices for the design of more inclusive ODeL environments. Viewed through an integrated theoretical lens, the findings suggest that collaborative learning is sustained through the interaction of social capital, connectivism and heutagogy rather than through technological provision alone (Blaschke & Hase 2015; Carr 2023; Mpungose 2025).
Social capital theory explains how students mobilised trusted relationships and broader learning networks to access emotional support, information and academic guidance. Connectivism extends this understanding by explaining how knowledge flowed across distributed networks that transcended institutional boundaries. Heutagogy provides further insight by demonstrating how students actively shaped their own learning environments through self-directed participation, selecting learning resources, communication channels and collaborative strategies that responded to their individual circumstances (Blaschke & Hase 2015; Narayan, Herrington & Cochrane 2019).
Importantly, learner autonomy did not emerge in isolation. Rather, self-determined learning was embedded in collaborative relationships and supported through interaction with peers. Students’ ability to establish learning networks, synchronise formal and informal learning spaces, and adapt to technological and contextual constraints demonstrates that autonomy and collaboration operate in mutually reinforcing ways. The findings therefore extend conventional understandings of learner autonomy by highlighting its relational and networked dimensions within digitally unequal ODeL environments (Blaschke & Hase 2015; Carr 2023; Mpungose 2025).
While self-directed learning is recognised as an important determinant of successful online learning (Doo & Zhu 2024), the findings suggest that learner autonomy is enacted through collaborative relationships and distributed learning networks rather than through individual self-direction alone (Blaschke & Hase 2015; Siemens 2005).
Taken together, the findings suggest that more inclusive ODeL requires learning environments that recognise student-created collaborative networks as legitimate educational spaces. Effective online learning therefore depends not only on technological access but also on opportunities for students to build social capital, participate in distributed learning networks, and exercise agency in shaping their own learning experiences, reinforcing conceptualisations of digital learning as fundamentally social and networked (Feng & Tan 2024; Mpungose 2025).
Implications for online learning design
Firstly, ODeL institutions should recognise the legitimate and complementary roles of formal and informal learning spaces. Rather than viewing student-created networks as peripheral to learning, course designers and lecturers should acknowledge their contribution to participation, support and knowledge sharing (Czerniewicz, Williams & Brown 2009). Designing opportunities that enable productive interaction across both formal and informal spaces may strengthen students’ learning experiences and reduce feelings of isolation (Mpungose 2025; Oddone 2023; Venter 2020, 2024).
Secondly, collaborative learning activities should be intentionally designed to support both bonding and bridging forms of social capital. Small-group interactions can foster trust, a sense of belonging, social presence and peer support, while activities that encourage interaction across groups can expose students to diverse perspectives and broader learning opportunities. Social presence, defined as the sense of being ‘real’ in an online environment, is foundational to sustained collaboration and meaningful engagement (Poellhuber, Anderson & Roy 2011). Design strategies such as personal profiles, introductory activities, and small-group cohorts can help students establish relational identities, shared histories, reciprocity and trust (Kear, Chetwynd & Jefferis 2014; Oztok 2013).
Trust is particularly important in heterogeneous and distributed learning groups, where students may be unfamiliar with one another and uncertain about expectations (Smith 2008). Learning designers and lecturers can cultivate psychological safety through transparent communication, flexible role structures, opportunities for group autonomy and visible support from lecturers. Effective collaborative design therefore requires a balance between familiarity and diversity, creating opportunities for students to develop both strong and weak network ties while fostering supportive, inclusive and trustworthy learning communities (Kear et al. 2014; Oztok et al. 2015).
Thirdly, learning activities should be responsive to the realities of digital inequality. Mobile-friendly resources, low-bandwidth communication options, flexible participation opportunities and asynchronous collaboration can help reduce barriers to participation for students with limited connectivity and technological resources (Makoe 2012).
Finally, the findings suggest that students benefit from opportunities to exercise autonomy in establishing and maintaining collaborative learning networks (Blaschke 2012). Learning design should therefore create space for student-led interaction, peer support and flexible pathways for engagement, while still providing sufficient structure to guide meaningful participation (Haworth 2016; Kehrwald & Oztok 2016; Venter 2020). Such an approach recognises students not only as participants in learning activities but also as active contributors to the creation and maintenance of learning networks. Recognising student-created informal learning networks as legitimate learning spaces may also contribute to more inclusive and contextually responsive ODeL practices (Czerniewicz et al. 2009; Makoe 2012; Mpungose 2025; Oddone 2023).
Limitations
Several limitations should be acknowledged. The study was conducted within a single online module at a South African ODeL institution and involved a relatively small, purposively selected sample of participants. While the sample was designed to capture diverse experiences of collaborative learning and varying levels of academic participation, broader demographic variables such as language, race, age, geographical location, and socio-economic status were not systematically collected or analysed. As a result, the study cannot provide detailed insights into how these intersecting factors may have influenced students’ experiences of collaborative learning and social capital formation.
Furthermore, the findings are context-specific and are not intended to be statistically generalisable to all ODeL environments. Rather, the study offers contextual and conceptual insights into how students utilise collaborative learning networks to navigate digital inequality and support their learning. The interpretations presented in this article are also shaped by the integrated conceptual framework of social capital theory, connectivism, and heutagogy, and alternative theoretical perspectives may yield different insights from the same dataset.
Recommendations for future research
This study highlights several opportunities for future research. Firstly, future research should examine how ODeL institutions can support student-created learning networks while preserving their flexibility and autonomy. Research examining the integration of formal and informal learning environments may provide insights into more inclusive and responsive approaches to ODeL design.
Secondly, future studies should explore how demographic and contextual factors, including language, socio-economic status, geographical location and digital access, influence participation in collaborative learning networks and the development of social capital. Such research may contribute to a deeper understanding of equity and inclusion in digitally mediated learning environments. Future research could examine student learning networks across formal and informal platforms using approaches such as social network analysis and educational data mining.
Lastly, future research could also examine collaborative learning and social capital across multiple ODeL institutions and disciplinary contexts, or employ longitudinal and mixed-methods designs to better understand how collaborative learning networks evolve over time and influence student success.
Conclusion
This study contributes to a deeper understanding of how collaborative learning supports the development of social capital in contexts of digital inequality within ODeL environments. The findings demonstrate that students draw on both bonding and bridging forms of social capital to access academic support, share knowledge, sustain motivation and engage with diverse perspectives. In doing so, they move between formal institutional platforms and informal learning networks, creating interconnected learning spaces.
The study further highlights collaborative learning as a socially embedded and networked process. Social capital theory, connectivist and heutagogical perspectives together explain how students navigate and sustain learning networks in response to contextual constraints.
More inclusive ODeL environments require learning designs that support social connection, trust, participation and flexibility while remaining responsive to digital inequality. Rather than viewing student-created networks as peripheral to learning, institutions should recognise their contributions to knowledge sharing, a sense of belonging and academic success. In this way, collaborative learning extends beyond a pedagogical strategy to become an important mechanism through which students negotiate access, participation and inclusion within digitally mediated higher education environments. These findings contribute to ongoing discussions about equity, participation and learner support in digitally mediated higher education and highlight the importance of recognising student-created learning networks as valuable educational resources.
Acknowledgements
This article is based on research originally conducted as part of Anneke Venter’s DLitt et Phil thesis titled ‘Social capital and online learning: the case of Unisa, South Africa’, submitted to the Faculty of Humanities, University of Johannesburg in 2018. The thesis was supervised by Tina Uys and Anton Senekal. The supervisors were not involved in the preparation of this manuscript and were not listed as co-authors. The manuscript has since been revised and adapted for journal publication. The original thesis is publicly available at: https://hdl.handle.net/10210/265162.
During the preparation of this work, the author used ChatGPT (OpenAI, 2026) for language refinement, formatting support and minor stylistic editing. The content was reviewed and edited by the author, who takes full responsibility for its accuracy.
Competing interests
The author declared that they have no financial or personal relationships that may have inappropriately influenced them in writing this article.
CRediT authorship contribution
Anneke Venter: Conceptualisation, Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Project administration, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing. The author confirms that this work is entirely their own, has reviewed the article, approved the final version for submission and publication, and takes full responsibility for the integrity of its findings.
Funding information
The author received no financial support for the research, authorship and/or publication of this article.
Data availability
The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author, Anneke Venter, upon reasonable request.
Disclaimer
The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and are the product of professional research. They do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of any affiliated institution, funder, agency or the publisher. The author is responsible for this article’s results, findings and content.
References
Blaschke, L.M., 2012, ‘Heutagogy and lifelong learning: A review of heutagogical practice and self-determined learning’, International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning 13(1), 56–71. https://doi.org/10.19173/irrodl.v13i1.1076
Blaschke, L.M. & Hase, S., 2015, ‘Heutagogy: A holistic framework for creating twenty-first-century self-determined learners’, in B. Gros, Kinshuk & M. Maina (eds.), The future of ubiquitous learning: Learning designs for emerging pedagogies, pp. 25–40, Springer, Berlin.
Bourdieu, P., 1986, ‘The forms of capital’, in J. Richardson (ed.), Handbook of theory and research for the sociology of education, pp. 241–258, Greenwood Press, New York, NY. https://www.gbv.de/dms/hebis-mainz/toc/009302689.pdf
Bozkurt, A. & Stracke, C.M., 2023, ‘The shift toward openness in education and the implications for learning ecosystems and ecologies’, in D. Otto, G. Scharnberg, M. Kerres & O. Zawacki-Richter (eds.), Distributed learning ecosystems: Concepts, resources and repositories, pp. 31–46, Springer VS, Wiesbaden.
Carr, T., 2023, ‘Book review: Co-teaching and co-research in contexts of inequality: Using networked learning to connect Africa and the world, edited by Phindile Zifikile Shangase, Daniela Gachago and Eunice Ndeto Ivala’, The International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning 24(4), 274–277. https://doi.org/10.19173/irrodl.v24i4.7523
Coleman, J.S., 1988, ‘Social capital in the creation of human capital’, American Journal of Sociology 94, S95–S120. https://doi.org/10.1086/228943
Czerniewicz, L. & Brown, C., 2013, ‘The habitus of digital “strangers” in higher education’, British Journal of Educational Technology 44(1), 44–53. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8535.2012.01281.x
Czerniewicz, L. & Carvalho, L., 2023, ‘Open, distance, and digital education (ODDE): An equity view’, in O. Zawacki-Richter & I. Jung (eds.), Handbook of open, distance and digital education, pp. 441–459, Springer, Singapore.
Czerniewicz, L., Williams, K. & Brown, C., 2009, ‘Students make a plan: Understanding student agency in constraining conditions’, Research in Learning Technology 17(2), 75–88. https://doi.org/10.1080/09687760903033058
Daniel, B.K., Schwier, R.A. & McCalla, G.I., 2003, ‘Social capital in virtual learning communities and distributed communities of practice’, Canadian Journal of Learning and Technology 29(3), 113–139. https://doi.org/10.21432/T21S4R
Doo, M.Y. & Zhu, M., 2024, ‘A meta-analysis of effects of self-directed learning in online learning environments’, Journal of Computer Assisted Learning 40(1), 1–20. https://doi.org/10.1111/jcal.12865
Downes, S., 2007, What connectivism is, Half an Hour Blog, viewed 10 February 2026, from https://www.downes.ca/post/33034.
Feng, S. & Tan, C.Y., 2024, ‘Toward conceptual clarity for digital cultural and social capital in student learning: Insights from a systematic literature review’, Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 11(1), 68. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-023-02519-8
Haworth, R., 2016, ‘Personal learning environments: A solution for self-directed learners’, TechTrends 60(4), 359–364. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11528-016-0074-z
Kear, K., Chetwynd, F. & Jefferis, H., 2014, ‘Social presence in online learning communities’, Research in Learning Technology 22, 1–15. https://doi.org/10.3402/rlt.v22.19710
Kehrwald, B. & Oztok, M., 2016, ‘Social presence and impression management: Understanding networked learners’ cultivation of learning networks’, in S. Cranmer, N.B. Dohn, M. de Laat, T. Ryberg & J.A. Sime (eds.), Proceedings of the 10th international conference on networked learning, Lancaster, United Kingdom, 9–11 May, pp. 225–233. https://doi.org/10.54337/nlc.v10.8867
Lephalala, M.M. & Makoe, M., 2012, ‘Socio-cultural issues for African distance students’, International Journal of E-Learning and Distance Education 26(1), viewed 15 September 2026, from https://www.ijede.ca/index.php/jde/article/view/759
Lu, J., Yang, J. & Yu, C.-S., 2013, ‘Is social capital effective for online learning?’, Information and Management 50(7), 507–522. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.im.2013.07.009
Makoe, M., 2016, ‘Teaching digital natives: Identifying competencies for mobile learning facilitators in distance education’, South African Journal of Higher Education 26(1), 91–104. https://doi.org/10.20853/26-1-152
Mpungose, C.B., 2025, ‘E-learning platforms at ODeL institutions of higher education: Creating a real-world learning’, Education and Information Technologies 30, 17207–17223. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10639-025-13447-2
Narayan, V., Herrington, J. & Cochrane, T., 2019, ‘Design principles for heutagogical learning’, in J. Keengwe (ed.), Handbook of research on emerging technologies for effective educational transformation, pp. 109–128, IGI Global, Hershey, PA.
Ngubane-Mokiwa, S.A., 2017, ‘Implications of Unisa’s shift to ODeL’, Australian Journal of Teacher Education 42(9), 111–124. https://doi.org/10.14221/ajte.2017v42n9.7
Oddone, K., 2023, ‘University educators’ experience of personal learning networks to enhance their professional knowledge’, International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning 24(3), 54–76. https://doi.org/10.19173/irrodl.v24i3.7053
Oztok, M., 2013, ‘Tacit knowledge in online learning: Community, identity, and social capital’, Technology, Pedagogy and Education 22(1), 21–36. https://doi.org/10.1080/1475939X.2012.720414
Oztok, M., Zingaro, D., Makos, A., Brett, C. & Hewitt, J., 2015, ‘Capitalizing on social presence: The relationship between social capital and social presence’, The Internet and Higher Education 26, 19–24. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.iheduc.2015.04.002
Poellhuber, B., Anderson, T. & Roy, N., 2011, ‘Distance students’ readiness for social media and collaboration’, International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning 12(6), 102–125. https://doi.org/10.19173/irrodl.v12i6.1018
Putnam, R.D., 2001, ‘Social capital: Measurement and consequences’, Isuma: Canadian Journal of Policy Research 2(Spring), 41–51.
Siemens, G., 2005, ‘Connectivism: A learning theory for the digital age’, International Journal of Instructional Technology and Distance Learning 2(1), 3–10, viewed 17 August 2026, from https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/7c7dd6c900c031b3685c761c72ebafdf3004caed
Smith, R.O., 2008, ‘The paradox of trust in online collaborative groups’, Distance Education 29(3), 325–340. https://doi.org/10.1080/01587910802395839
Venter, A., 2018, ‘Social capital and online learning: A case of Unisa’, D Litt et Phil thesis, The University of Johannesburg, viewed 02 February 2026, from https://hdl.handle.net/10210/265162.
Venter, A., 2019, ‘Social media and social capital in online learning’, South African Journal of Higher Education 33(3), 241–257. https://doi.org/10.20853/33-3-3105
Venter, A., 2020, ‘Synchronising informal and formal learning spaces to facilitate collaborative online learning’, Africa Education Review 17(6), 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1080/18146627.2021.1954536
Venter, A., 2024, ‘Exploring the downside to student online collaborations’, Independent Journal of Teaching and Learning 19(1), 64–78. https://doi.org/10.17159/ijtl.v19i1.18853
Zawacki-Richter, O., 2026, ‘Towards a systems-based framework for digital educational equity in open, distance, and digital education’, Open Praxis 18(2), 381–397. https://doi.org/10.55982/openpraxis.18.2.1243
Zawacki-Richter, O. & Jung, I. (eds.), 2022, Handbook of open, distance and digital education, Springer, Singapore.
|